Stessa is a well-known free rental analytics platform built for long-term landlords by Roofstock. RentReel is a short-term-rental-first bookkeeping and tax app built by an operator running five Airbnbs. This page compares them honestly: features, pricing, target users, and the specific line items where each one is stronger for STR operators in 2026.
Built by a 5-property STR operator · Launched July 2026 · direct founder access
Two products, two different jobs. Here's the 30-second answer.
You host on Airbnb, VRBO, or Booking.com; you file (or want to start filing) Schedule E as a short-term rental operator; and you care about the STR tax lever: REPS 750-hr status, §469 material participation, cost segregation, and the correct occupancy-tax split on 1099-K payouts.
You primarily own long-term single-family or small-multifamily rentals, you want free portfolio analytics and rent tracking without paying for software, and your Schedule E is straightforward: flat monthly rent in, ordinary expenses out, minimal tax strategy needed.
Every row is either something an STR-heavy portfolio actually uses at tax time, or a workflow the tool is designed around. No fluff rows.
| Feature | RentReel | Stessa |
|---|---|---|
| Built specifically for STR Stessa does ship a Short-term Rental unit type and STR expense categories: platform fees, cleaning, linens, occupancy tax. What it does not do is treat them as structure. RentReel classifies every property by average stay, reconciles Airbnb/VRBO/Booking payouts line by line, and carries occupancy-tax passthrough and cleaning fees straight through to the Schedule E. | ✓ | STR categories · LTR core |
| Schedule E export (multi-tab Excel) Real Excel workbook laid out like the IRS form: per-property tabs, line-by-line rollup, 1099 vendor tab. Send it to your CPA and they file from it. | ✓ | Tax Package (Excel/PDF) |
| REPS 750-hour tracker · IRC §469(c)(7) Log hours by activity/property so you can defensibly claim Real Estate Professional Status. For qualifying W-2-spouse households this can be worth five figures a year. Confirm with your CPA. | ✓ | ✗ |
| §469 material participation · live 500-hr + 100-hr gauges STRs with avg stay ≤ 7 days aren't rentals under §469. They're trades. Meeting a participation test allows non-passive loss treatment. RentReel gauges the two most common tests live with a full hours log. | ✓ | ✗ |
| AI 1098 mortgage extract Drop your 1098 PDF; RentReel pulls interest, property tax, PMI, and points automatically, and puts interest alone on Schedule E Line 12 (not full P&I). | ✓ | ✗ Manual |
| Hospitable / PMS CSV import Hospitable, Guesty, Hostaway, OwnerRez, Lodgify, or raw Airbnb/VRBO CSV, mapped and categorized on upload. | ✓ | Airbnb CSV importer + bank feeds |
| Mileage attribution across properties Stessa's mileage tab lets you pick the property and pulls the IRS standard rate, one manual entry at a time, and Stessa's own guidance tells multi-property owners to log a single portfolio-level total instead. RentReel logs the trip once: trips to a property's address land on that property, shared trips are allocated by revenue share (or an even split, or direct-only), and the IRS standard rate lands on each property's Schedule E Line 6. | ✓ auto-split per property | ✓ manual entry · property-assignable |
| CPA read-only share link Generate a URL, send to your CPA. No signup, no seat cost, no login. They see your Schedule E prep and export workpapers. Stessa's read-only collaborator role covers the viewing part, but your CPA needs a Stessa login to use it. | ✓ | collaborator · login req |
| Cost segregation estimator Rough estimate of building-cost reclass to 5/7/15-year property with bonus depreciation. Helps you decide if a $3 to $5K engineered study is worth it. | ✓ | ✗ |
| Bank / card CSV or PDF import (any US institution) RentReel accepts CSV or PDF from any US bank/card issuer. Stessa connects through financial data aggregators — its fact sheet names MoneyKit and Plaid — and is candid that bank connections "are inherently complex and sometimes unreliable." | ✓ | Plaid feeds |
| Property-level P&L See which listing actually nets after cleaning fees, supplies, and occupancy-tax passthrough, not just gross bookings. | ✓ | ✓ |
| Rental analytics · valuations · comps Stessa's home turf: free rental estimates, market comps, DSCR-style analysis. RentReel doesn't play here. | ✗ | ✓ |
| Native iOS / Android mobile app Stessa has full mobile apps for on-the-go tracking. RentReel is a mobile-optimized web app (installable as a PWA). No native app store presence yet. | PWA | iOS + Android |
| Target customer Product design, defaults, and integrations follow from this. | STR operators | LTR landlords |
| Pricing Stessa: Essentials free · Manage $12/mo · Pro $28/mo (annual pricing, as listed Sep 2026). The advanced reporting tier is the $28 one. RentReel has a free tier and adds the tax-loophole layer on paid plans. | $0–$129/mo | Free · $12 · $28/mo (Sep 2026) |
| Support responsiveness RentReel is founder-run. You can email Jordan directly. Stessa has scaled support with typical SaaS response times. | Direct founder access | Standard SaaS |
Free tier and brand recognition. Stessa's free plan is legitimately generous. You can track a large portfolio, pull Plaid bank feeds, run a portfolio dashboard, and see property valuations without paying a dollar. Backed by Roofstock, the brand has real weight in the long-term-rental community. Most LTR landlords have at least heard of it. For a landlord with three duplexes and a stable rent roll, the free tier is hard to beat.
Rental analytics and market data. Stessa surfaces automated property valuations, market rent estimates, and cash-flow analysis that RentReel doesn't try to replicate. If you buy and hold long-term properties and want an at-a-glance view of portfolio equity, DSCR, and cap rate trends, that lane is Stessa's home turf. RentReel intentionally stays in the tax/bookkeeping lane instead of building a competing analytics dashboard.
Mobile apps + Plaid feeds. Stessa has mature native iOS and Android apps and a well-worn Plaid integration. If you want to snap a receipt from your phone at Home Depot and see it flow to a property, Stessa's mobile flow is polished. RentReel runs as a mobile-optimized progressive web app you can install to your home screen, but there's no native app store presence today.
The tax loophole layer. If you're a short-term rental operator, the biggest dollars on your return come from REPS 750-hour status and §469 material participation. RentReel is the only bookkeeping app I know of that ships live §469 participation gauges (the 500-hour and 100-hour tests), a contemporaneous hours log, a Hours Reconstruction Wizard for prior years, and an aggregate-election toggle. Stessa doesn't touch this layer. It's a generic real-estate tool. If you're actively chasing the STR loophole, for qualifying operators that layer can be worth five figures a year. Confirm the numbers with your CPA.
Airbnb 1099-K accounting done right. When Airbnb pays you, that payout usually includes occupancy tax the guest paid, which is not your income. Treating it as revenue inflates your Schedule E and your tax bill. RentReel separates gross rent, cleaning fee revenue, and occupancy-tax passthrough automatically on import. Stessa does ship STR categories for this: Income > Short Term Rents, Taxes > Short Term Occupancy Taxes, and a Transfers > Taxes to Remit bucket, so the vocabulary is there. The difference is who does the splitting: Stessa expects you to assign those categories yourself against a payout that already nets rent, cleaning and tax into one deposit, and we couldn't find a collected-vs-remitted reconciliation per jurisdiction in it. RentReel does the split on upload and tracks what you owe each jurisdiction against what you've remitted. Same for AI 1098 extraction. Schedule E Line 12 asks for mortgage interest only, not principal, and RentReel gets that right on upload.
Schedule E export your CPA can actually use. RentReel produces a multi-tab Excel workbook laid out like the IRS Schedule E form: one tab per property, one summary tab, one 1099 vendors tab with blank W-9/TIN columns. Generate a read-only share link and your CPA reviews it in-app without a login or seat cost. Stessa ships a Schedule E report on its Manage tier and up, so the line mapping isn't the difference. The format is: RentReel gives your CPA a per-property multi-tab workbook with the 1099 vendor tab and the in-app review link, rather than a report you re-cut per entity. For an STR operator with 3+ properties across LLCs, that structure is what saves the time.
Skim your situation, jump to the answer.
You don't lose any historical data. Stessa lets you export everything you've entered. RentReel imports it back in.
In Stessa, go to Reports → Transactions → Export CSV. Grab full history, not just YTD. Download the property list too so you know which properties to create.
Start free at app.rentreel.co, no card required. Take 14 days of everything, then Investor is $79/mo if you subscribe (Solo is $39, Portfolio $129; annual saves about two months).
Add each property with its LLC and average stay length (RentReel classifies STR/MTR/LTR from the stay length). Then add the bank account the export came from and use that tile's Upload CSV button (or put the account's last four digits in the file name): the importer reads it as a standard transactions file and categorizes each row to a Schedule E line from the payee and description. Property and LLC assignment happens in RentReel after import, and learned payee rules make that quick.
Stessa's export is a standard transactions CSV. RentReel's importer reads it as transactions (Stessa's property column is not mapped yet, so you assign properties in RentReel), and anything it can't confidently categorize gets flagged for a quick review. Send us your export at support@rentreel.co and we'll help you map categories to Schedule E lines. Loop in your CPA via the read-only share link.
See if it fits your STR workflow before you pay a dollar. Start free, no card required. 14 days of everything; your books go read-only after unless you subscribe. No surprise charges. We never bill you without you adding a card.
Start free trial → See the demo firstPublic rate $79/mo Investor · rentreel.co